After Reading This Article You Can Solve This UPSC Mains PYQ (2020):
What are the major factors responsible for making rice-wheat system a success? In spite of this success how has this system become a bane in India? 15 marks (GS3, Agriculture)
Context
India’s position as the world’s largest rice exporter highlights a growing policy dilemma: sustaining export competitiveness while addressing groundwater depletion, energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions associated with intensive rice cultivation.
Introduction
India’s rice economy must transition from volume-driven production towards resource-efficient, high-value and climate-resilient agriculture to reconcile export growth with ecological sustainability and farmers’ long-term welfare.
Significance Of India’s Rice Economy: Dimension-Wise Analysis
1. Economic and Export Dimension
- Global export leadership: India has remained the world’s largest rice exporter since 2012, accounting for approximately 30–35% of global rice exports, strengthening its agricultural trade competitiveness.
- Foreign exchange earnings: Rice export value increased from $8.82 billion (2020–21) to $12.47 billion (2024–25), supporting export diversification and foreign exchange generation.
2. Agricultural and Farmers’ Income Dimension
- Livelihood security: Rice cultivation supports millions of farming households, agricultural labourers and allied enterprises, particularly in eastern and northern India.
- Value realisation: In 2025–26, Basmati exports earned approximately ₹50,138 crore from 6.52 million tonnes, highlighting the potential of premium varieties and quality-based exports.
3. Environmental and Water Security Dimension
- Groundwater sustainability: Intensive paddy cultivation in Punjab, Haryana and western Uttar Pradesh increases groundwater extraction, threatening long-term agricultural and drinking-water security.
- Virtual water trade: Rice exports indirectly transfer freshwater resources embedded in production, making blue-water consumption per tonne of exported rice an important sustainability indicator.
4. Climate and Ecological Dimension
- Greenhouse gas emissions: Flooded paddy fields generate methane, while excessive nitrogen fertiliser application contributes to nitrous oxide emissions, increasing agriculture’s climate footprint.
- Ecological sustainability: Intensive monocropping, excessive chemical inputs and repeated puddling can degrade soil health and reduce agro-biodiversity.
5. Food Security and Social Dimension
- National food security: Rice is a major staple food and an important component of India’s PDS and foodgrain procurement system, supporting nutritional and consumption security.
- Rural employment: Rice production generates employment across cultivation, milling, processing, transportation and agricultural marketing, strengthening rural livelihoods.
6. Technological and International Trade Dimension
- Agricultural modernisation: Technologies such as Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD), Direct Seeded Rice (DSR) and Integrated Nutrient Management (INM) improve resource-use efficiency and reduce environmental costs.
- Global strategic importance: India’s rice exports support food availability in developing countries, particularly in Africa and Asia, strengthening its position in international agricultural trade.
Major Challenges In Rebalancing India’s Rice Economy
1. Economic and Institutional Challenges
- MSP-procurement dependency: Assured procurement of rice and wheat in Punjab and Haryana reinforces water-intensive paddy cultivation and discourages crop diversification.
- Limited alternative markets: Inadequate procurement infrastructure and remunerative prices for pulses, oilseeds and millets make farmers reluctant to shift away from rice.
2. Groundwater Depletion and Irrigation Challenges
- Excessive groundwater extraction: Agriculture accounts for approximately 87% of India’s total groundwater extraction (213.29 BCM), intensifying pressure on aquifers in major rice-producing regions.
- Subsidised electricity: Free or highly subsidised agricultural power reduces groundwater pumping costs, encouraging excessive irrigation and inefficient water consumption.
3. Technological and Agronomic Challenges
- Limited DSR adoption: Weed infestation, specialised machinery requirements and inadequate technical knowledge restrict the adoption of Direct Seeded Rice.
- Research-extension gap: Inadequate access to climate-resilient seeds, precision irrigation and region-specific agricultural technologies limits sustainable farming practices.
4. Climate Change and Environmental Challenges
- Agricultural greenhouse gas emissions: Flooded paddy fields generate methane, while excessive nitrogen fertiliser application contributes to nitrous oxide emissions, increasing agriculture’s carbon footprint.
- Soil degradation: Continuous monocropping, repeated puddling and excessive chemical inputs adversely affect soil health, fertility and agro-biodiversity.
5. Food Security and International Trade Challenges
- Domestic-export trade-off: India’s rice export restrictions during 2022–24 demonstrated the difficulty of balancing domestic food security, consumer affordability and export competitiveness.
- Global market uncertainty: Geopolitical tensions, international price fluctuations and inconsistent export policies affect India’s reliability as a major global rice supplier.
Government Initiatives And Policy Measures
1. Pradhan Mantri Krishi Sinchayee Yojana (PMKSY)
The scheme promotes improved irrigation infrastructure, water conservation and efficient water utilisation through its Per Drop More Crop component.
2. Crop Diversification Programme (CDP)
Implemented under PM-RKVY, the programme encourages farmers in Punjab, Haryana and western Uttar Pradesh to shift from paddy towards pulses, oilseeds, millets and other alternative crops.
3. Soil Health Card Scheme
It provides farmers with information on soil nutrient status and recommendations for balanced fertiliser application, supporting efficient nutrient management.
Way Forward
1. Value-based Export Strategy: Promote premium Basmati, GI-tagged regional varieties, quality certification and modern processing to maximise export earnings per tonne rather than increasing export volumes.
2. Region-Specific Crop Diversification: Shift water-stressed regions towards pulses, millets and oilseeds through assured procurement, remunerative prices and transitional incentives for farmers.
3. Sustainable Water Management: Scale up Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD), Direct Seeded Rice (DSR), aquifer mapping and rainwater harvesting to improve irrigation efficiency and groundwater sustainability.
4. Low-Carbon Rice Cultivation: Promote Integrated Nutrient Management, methane-reducing irrigation practices, climate-resilient rice varieties and solar-powered irrigation to reduce agricultural emissions.
5. Technology-Driven Agricultural Governance: Strengthen ICAR research, KVK-based farmer training, satellite-based crop monitoring and a Water-Carbon-Value framework to measure resource efficiency and sustainable export performance.
Conclusion
India must move beyond measuring rice-sector success through production and export volumes alone. A sustainable rice economy should maximise farmers’ income and export value while minimising groundwater depletion, energy consumption and carbon emissions, ensuring long-term food and ecological security.
| Important Current to Concept From This Article for UPSC: Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD) Soil Health Card Scheme |